Cabot Cliffs: the 14th is the most photographed, the 17th is the better hole.
"Routing forces you into six different wind directions. Greens are faster than they look on the website. Bring two dozen balls and a sense of humor about your short game."
Course Reviews · Issue 27,400+
Where the room argues the routing, not the resort.
Twenty-seven years of members driving in, checking in, and writing what the scorecard won't tell you. Every review below was posted by a verified player who paid a green fee, signed a paper, and then told the rest of us exactly what was wrong with the 14th. Sorted by region, handicap band, and the season you actually play.
The Working Index
Most-debated, most-recent — a real-time cut of the database.
Four filters, no resort PR. Slice by region, handicap band, season played, or star rating. Every row links to the original thread with photo proof, posted scores, and the unedited member discussion that followed.
Turnberry Ailsa after the 2024 regrassing: faster, firmer, and unforgiving off the back tee.
"The new fescue runs forever. Members will love it; visitors who slice into the 11th will not. Caddie program is still the best value in UK golf — take one."
Pine Valley still isn't the #1 — and after my fourth visit, I'm done pretending it is.
"It's the most dramatic piece of land in American golf. It is also the most overrated if you can't keep the ball below the hole. Here's what the ranking panels miss."
Kapalua Plantation: the trade winds are real, the slope rating lies, and you will lose balls on 5.
"Played as a 14-handicapper. Shot 96. Worth every minute. Pro shop will fit you into a shaft you didn't ask for and you'll hit it better — heads up."
Showing 1–4 of 27,400+ verified reviews
Load the next 24 →
The Canon
Four courses the membership argues about every January.
A shortlist of the most-photographed, most-debated, most-cursed layouts in the database. None of them are here because a resort paid us. All of them are here because 200-plus members wrote a thread arguing about them.
#1 most-debated · Ireland
Old Head of Kinsale
"Eight holes you remember. Ten you wish you didn't have to play in 35-knot wind." — 312 reviews, average 4.3★.
Read the thread →
#2 most-photographed · Oregon
Bandon Dunes (Old Macdonald)
"The only course in the US where a 20-handicapper and a +2 both feel humbled by the same fairway." — 287 reviews, average 4.6★.
Read the thread →
#3 most-argued · North Carolina
Pinehurst No. 2 (post-2021 restoration)
"The turtleback greens are a psychological experiment. Bring three putters and a referee." — 264 reviews, average 4.4★.
Read the thread →
#4 most-cited · Surrey, England
Sunningdale Old
"The best walk in heathland golf. The greens are a legitimate 11 on the Stimpmeter. Don't bring a 30-handicap buddy expecting to enjoy it." — 218 reviews, average 4.5★.
Read the thread →
A note on credibility
"Every review in this database was written by a member who actually checked in. They post a handicap. They post a date. They post a photo of the scorecard — usually wrinkled, sometimes beer-stained. There is no resort PR in this archive. There is no anonymous five-star fluff. If a course is overrated, we say so. If a muni is better than the panel lists, we say so louder."
- Verified check-in. Photo proof required for every published review.
- Handicap disclosed. Reviewers post a current handicap index band (0–6, 7–15, 16–22).
- Date stamped. Greens change. Reviews older than 18 months are flagged for a re-check.
- Replies unedited. Discussion threads stay open. Disagreements are the point.
Membership · $24 lifetime
Stop reading reviews. Start writing the next one.
27,400 reviews and counting. The only way it grows is if the next round you play gets posted the week you play it. Join the forum, post your handicap, and add to the canon.
Funded entirely by members since the 2016 referendum. No third-party ad trackers. No data resale. No corporate spin.